How to Determine Whether to Repair or Replace Your Plumbing Pipes

San Rafael

(415) 942-6565

Santa Rosa

(707) 452-3464

Determining Whether to Repair or Replace Your Plumbing Pipes

As plumbing pipes age, they become more susceptible to leaks, cracks, blockages, and other issues that can wreak havoc in your home. This is why watching for signs that your pipes may need maintenance or a complete replacement is essential. However, deciding whether repair or replacement is the right solution can sometimes be tricky. Here are some tips to help you determine the best course of action for your plumbing system.

Check for Signs of Wear and Tear

Start by inspecting your pipes for visible wear and tear that could signal problems down the line. Look for:

  • Rust or corrosion buildup: This indicates the metal is deteriorating and weakening over time.
  • Pinhole leaks: Small, slow leaks can indicate advanced corrosion, even if not visible externally. 
  • Cracks or fractures: Physical damage from shifts in the foundation or other factors can crack older pipes.
  • Bulges or strange contours: Internal pooling of water or pressure buildup can cause the pipe to expand in odd ways.

Pay attention to areas near joints and fittings, as these are more prone to leaks. Extensive oxidation or other damage means the pipe material has reached the end of its useful life span and needs replacement.

Consider the Pipe Material

The material your pipes are made from determines their durability and replacement needs. For example:

  • When appropriately installed, copper piping lasts, on average, 50-75 years. It’s durable but expensive to replace.
  • PVC and CPVC last around 50 years and are flexible repair options, but due to their chlorine content, they break down over decades. 
  • Galvanized steel lasts 30-50 years but is prone to rusting and corrosion much faster than other metals in high-pH areas.
  • Polybutylene pipes only lasted 10-20 years and needed replacing en masse in the 1990s due to failures. 

Knowing your material type helps predict remaining viability and repair feasibility. Replacing very old galvanized steel pipes, for instance, may be better than multiple repairs.

Check the Pipe Layout 

Take note of your pipe layout and any issues that could affect repairs. For example:

– Embedded pipes behind walls make repairs and inspection difficult. 

  • Improper placement, such as pipes running through exterior walls without protection from freeze/thaw cycles, leads to shorter lifespans.
  • Tight bends or joints make snaking or camera inspections challenging.
  • Improper installation techniques and materials accelerated wear over time.

A complex, confined, or improperly installed original layout increases the hassle of repairs versus a full overhaul.

Test for Leaks and Blockages

Rather than guess if issues exist, test your plumbing system to know for sure. A few options:

  • Use leak-detection dye tablets to check for unseen cracks or pinholes underground.
  • Perform sewer camera inspections to check for tree roots, cracks, and corrosion inside drain lines. 
  • Pressure tests are done by capping ends and monitoring pressure drops that signify leaks. 
  • Pour water down drains while watching for backups to discover slow drainage problems.

Pinpointing real issues helps decide between low-cost repairs versus more involved replacement projects.

Consider Your Repair vs Replacement Costs

Tally up the costs of repairs over time versus a single replacement investment to see which provides better long-term value. Factors:

  • Over a few years, multiple patchwork repairs often surpass a single replacement cost in the long run. 
  • New plumbing installs come with a warranty versus repair work with no guarantee. 
  • Replacing allows choosing high-quality, longer-lasting materials like PEX tubing for future cost savings.
  • DIY repairs save money over contractors but increase labor costs if issues persist.

Weigh predictable long-term costs of a repipe versus uncertain repair bills. Replacing may be more affordable in the long run.

Think About Disruptions

Plumbing repairs often require digging, jackhammering concrete, and navigating tight access areas. This leads to more disruptions, noise, and mess for homeowners versus replacement:

  • Repairs disrupt daily activities and cause recurring messes until issues are resolved.
  • Replacement is a significant one-time disruption that’s done once pipes, fixtures, and everything else are modernized. 

Depending on your situation and planned renovations, fewer repeated disruptions may be preferable.

Consider Your Home’s Overall Condition

An outdated plumbing system may be the least common problem in an aging home. If other areas also need renovating, it makes sense to repipe as part of a broader remodel. For example:

  • Dated electric wiring, roof, or siding indicates a home due for improvements. 
  • Remodels or additions shifting floor layouts require moving pipe locations. 
  • Home sales or increased property value could recoup renovation costs.

Coupling plumbing upgrades into broader renovations yields a cohesive, efficient project with synergistic cost savings.

When in Doubt, Consult a Plumber

If you’re unsure whether repair or replacement is proper, speak to a trusted plumber. They can perform thorough inspections and material testing and use years of experience to advise you. Consider:

  • Local water quality, soil composition, and freeze/thaw potential impact pipe viability.
  • Understanding failure risks like root intrusion or post-installation problems.
  • Knowledge of local codes and standards that may require certain upgrades at a repipe. 

An expert evaluation helps weigh all critical factors for an informed decision about your best next steps. Don’t hesitate to get a second opinion if needed.

With a proper assessment of your plumbing system’s condition, material, layout, costs, and other key variables, you’ll be well-equipped to choose wisely between repair and replacement. Prioritizing a durable long-term solution prevents recurrent plumbing problems and protects your home’s value for years.

Need Help?

We’re open Monday – Friday 7:30am – 5:30pm, call today or schedule online now!

Serving Marin & Sonoma Counties

Good plumbing, heating, and air conditioning systems are vital in every North California home. John Owens Services, Inc. is proud to be the expert plumbing company you can count on

The John Owens Way

Our philosophy is simple, we always want to maintain equipment to give it the longest life possible. Next, we want to focus on repairing when something goes wrong. Then only as the last choice, we replace equipment when needed. That’s the John Owens Way.

San Rafael
(415) 942-6565
Santa Rosa
(707) 452-3464



Regular maintenance keeps your home’s systems running well all year long. We’ll help you gain efficiency and save money.



When something breaks down, our team will get to you fast. We’ll find the problem and fix it to get you back to normal.



When it’s time to replace something in your home, we’ll help you get a top quality product that matches your specific needs.
San Rafael
(415) 942-6565
Santa Rosa
(707) 452-3464